SALEM — A New Hampshire woman who was arrested after police say she tried to bring a loaded handgun into the Ruane Judicial Center Monday will remain held without bail, a judge ordered Friday.
Salem District Court Judge Robert Brennan said he found Ashley Papatola’s varying explanations to court officers and police about why the gun was in her purse as she tried to enter the Salem courthouse “not terribly credible.”
Papatola, 29, of Londonderry, New Hampshire, was at the Federal Street court complex Monday afternoon for the sentencing of Jonuel Carattini, 36 — a man she variously described as her boyfriend and husband — on heroin trafficking and gun charges. Unbeknownst to her, that sentencing had been delayed shortly before she arrived.
The gun was concealed in a zippered compartment in her handbag, but showed up on the X-ray as an associate court officer screened the bag.
Prosecutor Erin Bellavia highlighted Papatola’s three different explanations to various officials as to how the gun happened to be in the bag.
“It’s very far-fetched and unbelievable,” said the prosecutor.
Papatola initially told court officers, “I can’t believe I put that in there,” and said she’d gone back to her car to leave her Mace there. But later, she said she’d taken a knife out of her bag to leave in her car.
She also told the court officer she knew the gun was loaded.
Later, she told Salem Patrolman Katherine Monk that she’d forgotten that the gun was in the bag, then “I meant to take it out,” but got distracted.
“She tells three different stories as to what she knows about the gun,” said Bellavia.
She was less than candid about other things as well, refusing to say how or when the gun was loaded, with 10 hollow-point bullets.
She also neglected to mention Carattini’s gun charges when asked why she was at the courthouse; Bellavia showed the judge documents that revealed that Carattini was also found to have a .40 caliber handgun.
Patrolman Deejay Gagnon testified during the hearing that after he removed the gun from the purse, it was significantly lighter.
Bellavia recalled that testimony for the judge, telling Brennan, “I just find it hard to believe she didn’t know the gun was in her purse.”
Defense lawyer Scott Gleason, who also represents Carattini, told the judge that Papatola was under stress as a result of Carattini’s conviction and a pending 3 1/2 year minimum mandatory sentence.
Gleason referred to Carattini as Papatola’s husband, and Papatola testified under the name “Ashley Carattini” during his trial.
“It’s been a terrible time for her,” said Gleason. Carattini was the sole support of Papatola and their 10-month-old son, said the lawyer.
Gleason also suggested that Papatola’s methadone treatment was not the result of past heroin use, as she told police, according to the police reports, but of a rogue doctor who overprescribed pain medication.
And, he suggested, prosecutors have not found any evidence that Papatola and Carattini conspired to have her bring the gun to court.
Brennan, the judge, said that while he agrees that Papatola was “desperate and emotional” in her videotaped police interview, he noted her history of opiate addiction. And he said he was taking into account the fact that Papatola had been at the courthouse multiple times, including during Carattini’s trial, and had remembered to take the gun out of her bag on those dates.
“It does strain credulity or common sense,” said Brennan, “how someone thinks they might get a gun past security, except that it has happened in this state before.”
And while Papatola had, until Monday, a valid permit to carry a concealed handgun in New Hampshire, it is not valid in Massachusetts.
The judge pointed to the “enormous signs” that appear on highways at the New Hampshire-Massachusetts border warning about the state’s gun laws, saying it’s impossible for Papatola to have missed those.
A pretrial conference is scheduled for June 23.
Courts reporter Julie Manganis can be reached at 978-338-2521, by email at Media or on Twitter at @SNJulieManganis.
How To Have A Fantastic Bellavia Chevrolet Buick With Minimal Spending | bellavia chevrolet buick – bellavia chevrolet buick
| Delightful in order to my personal website, in this moment I’m going to explain to you regarding keyword. Now, this is actually the 1st picture:
Why don’t you consider photograph over? is actually in which remarkable???. if you think maybe thus, I’l l explain to you a number of image again down below:
So, if you desire to have the awesome photos related to (How To Have A Fantastic Bellavia Chevrolet Buick With Minimal Spending | bellavia chevrolet buick), click save button to store these pics in your pc. They’re available for down load, if you’d rather and want to get it, just click save badge on the article, and it will be instantly downloaded in your computer.} Lastly if you need to obtain unique and latest picture related to (How To Have A Fantastic Bellavia Chevrolet Buick With Minimal Spending | bellavia chevrolet buick), please follow us on google plus or save this page, we try our best to offer you regular up-date with all new and fresh images. Hope you love staying right here. For some up-dates and recent news about (How To Have A Fantastic Bellavia Chevrolet Buick With Minimal Spending | bellavia chevrolet buick) pics, please kindly follow us on twitter, path, Instagram and google plus, or you mark this page on book mark area, We try to offer you up grade regularly with fresh and new photos, enjoy your searching, and find the perfect for you.
Thanks for visiting our site, contentabove (How To Have A Fantastic Bellavia Chevrolet Buick With Minimal Spending | bellavia chevrolet buick) published . At this time we are pleased to declare that we have found an incrediblyinteresting nicheto be reviewed, that is (How To Have A Fantastic Bellavia Chevrolet Buick With Minimal Spending | bellavia chevrolet buick) Many individuals trying to find details about(How To Have A Fantastic Bellavia Chevrolet Buick With Minimal Spending | bellavia chevrolet buick) and of course one of them is you, is not it?